The amount of research a parent would have to do is alarming. The fact that it's expected and not just taken care of for us is degrading.
I admit, one can get carried away with the natural stuff. You have to have more time and money than I have, to go totally organic, made from scratch, crunchy-munchy-all-the-time. I respect it, but can't do it. It's possible, but not practical.
We choose our battles here. We do organic milk, because it's consumed by the girls gallon by gallon, and because the hormone thing scares me to pieces. But we buy regular meat, because we aren't growing money trees out back. Our cups are all BPA free, as of last summer when the shit hit the fan on that one. We avoid high fructose corn syrup when we can, and try not to dwell on the one cup of Yoplait yogurt I ate each day of my pregnancy with Keelyn, which apparently contains mercury. And I'm supposed to be comforted by the suggestion that it's only small traces. Like any traces are okay. I limited my fish consumption, all the while eating mercury laden yogurt. And I'm not alone.
We've seriously considered moving to the boonies, buying some chickens, and calling it a day. But then, there'd be some sort of coup to keep, I imagine. And I've never thought of myself as much of a coup keeper.
It's interesting, really. The consumers kind of won the BPA thing. The media made a big deal of it, despite the FDA's continuous claim that the plastic was safe (this, determined by a study conducted by the plastics industry). But when consumers made angry phone calls, and sent angry letters...and when the Born Free website was out of stock on every cup...other manufacturers realized the demand, and one year later it's difficult to find a cup in Target that doesn't display a screaming bright notice that it is, in fact, BPA free. Now, the FDA admits there may be relevance to the rumors. They're looking into it...but I'm not holding my breath.
So, why then, pray tell, does the FDA not respond to the threats presented by particular food additives and dyes? And further, why do the manufacturers not do it for them? And if you don't know why I'm asking these questions, then you probably qualify as one of the many parents who doesn't have the time to look into all of these things...what, with the kids, and laundry, and life, and dishes, and life, and jobs, and oh yeah, kids...until they're staring you down.
I was stared down cold on Sunday. We first offered Keelyn Kraft Mac 'n' Cheese a few months ago, alongside Big Sissy who could pretty much live off the stuff. We noticed that her face got a little blotchy around the mouth, but honestly thought it to be contact dermatitis in a kid just a little young for the greasiness. Didn't seem to bother her, but was concerning when it happened a bit more severely, on another occasion. So, we gave it a few months. Sunday, we tried again. This time, her face was covered in hives. Big, itchy, welty hives. This, about 30 seconds after eating only 10 noodles. A few seconds and some gagging later, we gave her Benadryl, and she was fine within minutes.
Our doctor had mentioned based on my previous concern, that there is the possibility of food dye allergies, but generally this is in kids with asthma, and other allergies as well. After raiding our pantry and fridge, to find that in fact, nothing else she's ever eaten contains Yellow 5, I headed for the computer for some validation. I was blown away.
I was amazed. Disgusted. Kinda mad. But not surprised.
I think I might remember hearing about this randomly a few years back. I'm familiar with the thought that there is a possible link between popular food dyes and hyperactivity...I even know parents who swear by it, with their own children to prove it. But an allergy? One that can't just be argued away by saying that there could be other causes, or that the studies aren't conclusive? One that is plastered across the mouth of a child, staring me in the face, red and blotchy, with tears in her eyes? One that is apparently "uncommon" as in only 1 in 10,000 people have it...but is common enough (and concern enough) that the FDA requires it to be listed on food labels, tested by them before distribution, and the Food Standards Agency even calls for voluntary removal in foods by 2009? It's 2009!
This is madness.
And don't get me started on the countries who have already banned its use. What? Are they just smarter than us? More concerned for their citizens? Dare I say, less concerned for the big guy who wants to make the cheapest stuff he can at the threat of our children? How is this any different than allowing toxins in paint and baby formula?
And, why is the suggestion for removal merely voluntary? Why does the food have to be that yellow? Annie's makes great organic mac 'n' cheese, sans the tartrazine. My kids love it. It's still yellow. It just costs more.
So I guess I just don't get it. If it's possible to make foods without additives that have adverse affects on a large enough portion of the population that I can find information on it so quickly, why the additives? Cost isn't the answer. Remove the additives, settle for pasta that's a little less yellow, and save a step in the whole manufacturing process...SAVE money. Right? It seems so logical.
It's kind of like salt. If you never use it, you taste the food for what it is, and your palette adjusts. I'd imagine the eyes of a three year old would adjust as well. But how will a three year old adjust to having to forgo a treat in preschool because she's allergic? And why, in a society that knows your kids should no longer drink from a garden hose, do we allow such new things to be introduced into our foods and beverages? Sure, our parents survived it, and my grandma used to play with mercury as a kid...but we know better.
And we don't need yellow pasta.
Why should my daughter, along with many others, spend her whole life avoiding something so unnecessary in the first place?
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
After a while, I'm numb to the insult.
Posted by Mama Cass at 1:33 PM
Labels: BPA HFCS and other things that piss me off, parenting
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

6 comments:
I loved your post! My gosh...I get so sick of this crap. I try and do what I can, but I think just what we've all said before...moderation. Sometimes you just can't avoid it, even paying a pretty penny. I'm sorry to hear about Keelyn, story of my life with Hayden, but just causes. I actually am allergic to orange flavored things. It's amazing, I get SO hyper. Scott thinks it's the funniest thing in the world. ANyways, I feel your pain, and my sister and I were just talking about trying not to eat the High Fructose corn syrups and oils the other day, but it's so hard not to get them some. Also, about it being bad during pregnancy especially, but what is a person suppose to do.
Cassidy, you are right. Dyes and additives in food are causing many problems in children today, and frankly, they are just not necessary. I taught a child who was removed from all dyes (to help with her adhd) and it worked amazingly well! I know teach a 3-year old at church and her mom has just started her on this diet, and its affecting her behavior for the better as well. Crazy how they affect different kids! But so glad that you discovered what is causing Keelyn to react... And let me know if you need a homemade mac-n-cheese recipe! It's not as cheap as Kraft, but it tastes better and makes a whole lot more! My kids eat it up!
Cassidy--Do you remember clear coke? I wonder if that had anything to do with the dyes. As a non-parent hoping to have children soon, the whole thing is just so intimidating I can hardly even stand it. I love Diet Mountain Dew, which is just loaded with Yellow #5 and, interestingly, they warn both of you against if you are trying to conceive (not to mention the artificial sweeteners, but I digress). I did research on the Methyl Mercury issue when I was working at the Brookings Institution in 2001. The industry knew about this long before the public knew. My theory is that corporations are hesitant to yank products from the market in the name of safety in fear of a class action law suit. This begs the question--why not quietly replace the harmful ingredients? Your guess is as good as mine on that one.
I think Kraft has an all natural variety now that is carried at the yuppie grocery stores (you know, the ones near where we grew up that weren't yuppie then).
xo,
Emily
I totally understand your pain. I just want to give my kids good food and not have to pay a billion dollars doing it. It's also really hard finding food for them without dye or high fructose corn syrup or some other crazy thing in it. I would love to say I had the time or patience to make all homemade food, but I don't. I may try making a couple things on the weekend when Jon is home. At least it will help a little. We use Annie's too and my kids love it. It does cost more though. Let's just hope that someday soon they will take all dyes and such out of all our food.
Feel ya. We do organic milk, and that is about it for organic. My god, that is expensive. And, we do Amy's sometimes, but my kids don't really like it, and the costs are so high. There really is so much to worry about. I suppose, though, at least we have the information and the OPTION to worry about it. I think it would be great if manufacturers worried about our kids, too. Surely, there are alternatives, even if they lost a penny or two. It is a money world out there. But, boy, I am too exhausted and not rich enough to go all-out "crunchy." I feel so guilty when I see those perfect "whole foods moms," knowing I am incapable of being one. Who knows: maybe tomorrow they will find something wrong with all of that stuff, too. Just doing the best I can. Hoping it is enough.
when keelyn goes to preschool you will need to write a book about her allergy and then still stay on top of your very well intentioned teachers, i know bc i fight this battle with my kids dairy allergies 24/7 it feels like. stella has learned to warn folks about dairy herself and has learned what not to eat when offered to her and she is only 2 1/2. i assume it will get easier for her in time. the real hard part is when you have to tell each party hostest about the allergy and to ask if you can provide your own safe cupcake to avoid a no cake meltdown. but i'm here for ya thought it all. and my advice is simple- whole foods. they aren't expensive, they also aren't the most convienent. but if you make your own mac anc cheese its way cheaper than craft, lasts longer, and tastes better. i have a great reciepe if you want.
Post a Comment